TY - JOUR TI - Learning Processes in the Judge–Advisor System : A Neglected Advantage of Advice Taking AU - Schultze, Thomas AU - Stern, Alexander AU - Schulz-Hardt, Stefan PY - 2025 SP - 1-15 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109925 LA - eng AB - Previous research in the judge–advisor paradigm has focused on how judges utilize the wisdom of others by taking their advice and on the beneficial effect of receiving advice on judges' postadvice final judgments about the exact same problem. However, a completely different possibility of how judges might benefit from advice has been overlooked so far: Learning processes could improve the accuracy of judges' subsequent initial judgments from one problem to another problem on the same type of task as well. Hence, we test the assumption that advice can induce individual performance enhancements that differ as a function of the advisor's judgment accuracy. The results of three experiments support our hypothesis and indicate positive learning, particularly when participants receive high-quality advice. Furthermore, we show that external information about the advisor's accuracy is not crucial for the occurrence of these individual performance enhancements. In general, our results suggest that advice can have a positive effect on judges' subsequent initial judgments. KW - advice taking KW - decision making KW - estimation accuracy KW - judgment KW - learning ER - TY - JOUR TI - Learning Processes in the Judge–Advisor System : A Neglected Advantage of Advice Taking AU - Schultze, Thomas AU - Stern, Alexander AU - Schulz-Hardt, Stefan PY - 2025 JO - Journal of behavioral decision making VL - 38 IS - 3, e70029 SP - 1-15 PB - Wiley CY - Chichester [u.a.] SN - 1099-0771 DO - 10.1002/bdm.70029 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109881 LA - eng AB - Previous research in the judge–advisor paradigm has focused on how judges utilize the wisdom of others by taking their advice and on the beneficial effect of receiving advice on judges' postadvice final judgments about the exact same problem. However, a completely different possibility of how judges might benefit from advice has been overlooked so far: Learning processes could improve the accuracy of judges' subsequent initial judgments from one problem to another problem on the same type of task as well. Hence, we test the assumption that advice can induce individual performance enhancements that differ as a function of the advisor's judgment accuracy. The results of three experiments support our hypothesis and indicate positive learning, particularly when participants receive high-quality advice. Furthermore, we show that external information about the advisor's accuracy is not crucial for the occurrence of these individual performance enhancements. In general, our results suggest that advice can have a positive effect on judges' subsequent initial judgments. KW - advice taking KW - decision making KW - estimation accuracy KW - judgment KW - learning ER - TY - JOUR TI - The development of a task to study advice taking across nations and its application in a China-Germany comparison AU - Schultze, Thomas AU - Chen, Zhijun PY - 2025 JO - Judgment and decision making / Society for Judgment and Decision Making VL - 20 IS - e8 SP - 1-28 PB - Cambridge University Press CY - Cambridge SN - 1930-2975 DO - 10.1017/jdm.2024.43 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/107538 LA - eng AB - Advice taking is a crucial part of decision-making and has attracted the interest of scholars across the world. Laboratory research on advice taking has revealed several robust phenomena, such as sensitivity to advice quality or a tendency to underutilize advice. Despite extensive investigations in different countries, cultural differences in advice taking remain understudied. Knowing whether such cultural differences exist would not only be interesting from an academic standpoint but might also have consequences for multinational organizations and businesses. Here, we argue that prior laboratory research on cultural differences in advice taking is hindered by confounding factors, particularly the confound between participants’ cultural background and task difficulty. To draw a valid conclusion about cultural differences in advice taking, it is vital to develop a decision task devoid of this confound. Here, we develop such a judgment task and demonstrate that the core phenomena of advice taking manifest in a sample of German participants. We then use this task in a cross-national comparison of German and Chinese participants. While the core phenomena of advice taking consistently manifested in both samples, some differences emerged. Most notably, Chinese participants were more receptive of advice, even though they still underutilized it. This greater reliance on advice was driven by Chinese participants’ greater preference for averaging their own and the advisor’s judgments. We discuss how our findings extend current understanding of the nuanced interplay between cultural values and the dynamics of advice taking. KW - advice taking KW - cultural differences KW - quantitative judgment ER -