TY - JOUR TI - Delayed-Onset Adjustment Disorder After Accident-Related Injuries : A Retrospective Analysis of Legal Cases AU - Baum, Lilly A. AU - Klett, Noah AU - Capito, Eva Susanne AU - Schütz, Astrid Lioba AU - Gruner, Beate AU - Grömer, Teja Wolfgang PY - 2026 SP - 1-15 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/118025 LA - eng AB - An adjustment disorder (AjD) is defined as a maladaptive response to an identifiable stressor, with symptoms expected to emerge within up to three months of that stressor. Recent evidence, however, indicates that AjD symptoms may appear long after the onset of that stressor, especially with chronic illness or ongoing stress. We conducted a retrospective exploratory analysis of 22 validity-checked forensic cases retained after the screening of 597 medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs). We examined onset latency relative to the index event and whether later or ongoing accident-related stressors were documented in proximity to AjD onset. In ~82% of cases, a clinically significant AjD developed after three months post-injury/illness, well beyond the acute aftermath of the incident. In approximately 55% of the cases, loss of recovery expectancy (LRE) was documented as a lateroccurring accident- or illness-related stressor. Exploratory exact Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney tests compared GPQ and SIMS scores between onset groups and GPQ scores between cases with and without LRE. The findings suggest that AjD symptoms may emerge long after the index event while still occurring in temporal proximity to later or ongoing accident-related stressors. These observations are preliminary and do not establish a definitive delayed-onset subtype or a causal trajectory. KW - adjustment disorder KW - delayed-onset KW - medical expert witness assessments KW - forensics KW - work-related accident KW - work-related illness ER - TY - JOUR TI - Delayed-Onset Adjustment Disorder After Accident-Related Injuries : A Retrospective Analysis of Legal Cases AU - Baum, Lilly A. AU - Klett, Noah AU - Capito, Eva Susanne AU - Schütz, Astrid Lioba AU - Gruner, Beate AU - Grömer, Teja Wolfgang PY - 2026 JO - Behavioral Sciences VL - 16 IS - 11 SP - 1-15 PB - MDPI AG CY - Basel SN - 2076-328X DO - 10.3390/bs16112099 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/118012 LA - eng AB - An adjustment disorder (AjD) is defined as a maladaptive response to an identifiable stressor, with symptoms expected to emerge within up to three months of that stressor. Recent evidence, however, indicates that AjD symptoms may appear long after the onset of that stressor, especially with chronic illness or ongoing stress. We conducted a retrospective exploratory analysis of 22 validity-checked forensic cases retained after the screening of 597 medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs). We examined onset latency relative to the index event and whether later or ongoing accident-related stressors were documented in proximity to AjD onset. In ~82% of cases, a clinically significant AjD developed after three months post-injury/illness, well beyond the acute aftermath of the incident. In approximately 55% of the cases, loss of recovery expectancy (LRE) was documented as a lateroccurring accident- or illness-related stressor. Exploratory exact Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney tests compared GPQ and SIMS scores between onset groups and GPQ scores between cases with and without LRE. The findings suggest that AjD symptoms may emerge long after the index event while still occurring in temporal proximity to later or ongoing accident-related stressors. These observations are preliminary and do not establish a definitive delayed-onset subtype or a causal trajectory. KW - adjustment disorder KW - delayed-onset KW - medical expert witness assessments KW - forensics KW - work-related accident KW - work-related illness ER - TY - JOUR TI - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases of Claimed Reduced Work Capacity AU - Klett, N. AU - Dohrenbusch, R. AU - Fischer, A. AU - Geiger, T. AU - Keller, F. AU - Kornhuber, J. AU - Littke, O. AU - Schütz, A. AU - Siegmann, E.M. AU - Käfferlein, W. AU - Grömer, T. AU - Capito, E.S. PY - 2026 SP - 1-11 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115614 LA - eng AB - Medical Expert Witness Assessments (MEWA) are international standard to generate information involving medical questions in litigations, such as the capacity to work. While this procedure is widely utilized and guidelines for assessing the validity of symptoms using psychometric tools and non-psychometric criteria have been developed, the scientific foundation of this multimodal Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) is weak. This study aims to provide empirical validation of CVA using psychometric Symptom (SVT) and Performance Validity Tests (PVT) as areference point. 466 MEWA conducted in the law of the German Statutory Pension Insurance (GPI), all uniformly having addressed the question of the capacity to work, were analyzed. Information about scores regarding the Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS), Amsterdam Short-Term Memory Test (ASTM) aswell as the seven CVA criteria were extracted. A logistic regression using CVA data to group the MEWA into plausible and implausible (over- and/or under reporting of symptoms) cases showed a significant association between implausible cases and SIMS scores (OR= 1. 067; 95%- CI [1.037, 1.098]; p<. 0 01) as well as ASTM scores (OR= 0.965; 95%- CI [0.936, 0.994]; p<.05). In this highly comparable real-world dataset, we find evidence that CVA is indeed a valid tool in terms of convergent validity using a SVT and PVT as the point of reference and provide descriptive data on SVT and PVT that facilitates the interpretation of psychometric test results in such cases. KW - Criteria-Based validity assessment KW - Validation KW - Medical expert witness assessment KW - Pension insurance KW - Symptom validity test KW - Performance validity test ER - TY - JOUR TI - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance AU - Klett, N. AU - Dohrenbusch, R. AU - Siegmann, E.M. AU - Schütz, A. AU - Kornhuber, J. AU - Röhner, J. AU - Keller, F. AU - Capito, E.S. AU - Grömer, T. PY - 2026 SP - 1-16 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115554 LA - eng AB - Background: Medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs) evaluate case validity on the basis of both psychometric and non-psychometric modalities. Although symptom validity tests (SVTs) and performance validity tests (PVTs) are widely used, many thresholds were developed in analogue and known-groups validation contexts, and their transferability to MEWAs remains uncertain. Prior research validated a Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) as a multimodal framework for assessing case plausibility, but it remained unclear whether CVA and psychometric thresholds perform similarly across different legal contexts, such as pension insurance versus accident insurance evaluations. Objective: This study aimed to investigate differences in CVA, SVT, and PVT results across pension and accident insurance cases. Methods: A total of 721 MEWAs (572 pension; 149 accident) were analyzed. CVA criteria were rated by trained raters, and response biases were assessed psychometrically using the SIMS and the ASTM. Two-component beta-binomial mixture models were applied to derive CVA plausibility thresholds. Results: Mixture modeling reliably identified a distinct bimodal distribution of conspicuous CVA criteria counts, interpreted as plausible and implausible subgroups in both pension and accident cases, with ≥4 conspicuous CVA criteria representing the optimal plausibility threshold. Pension claimants showed significantly higher SIMS scores and lower ASTM scores than accident claimants, independent of case plausibility. Conclusion: CVA can be used to assess validity information collected from multiple data sources (longitudinal and cross-sectional) and to assess the validity of health-related claims across different legal settings. CVA, however, was not a tool for measuring context-specific response biases. Cases with ≤2 conspicuous CVA criteria may be valid, cases with three conspicuous criteria require individual examination because feigning is possible but not certain, and ≥4 conspicuous criteria supported a conservative classification of CVA-defined case implausibility. KW - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment KW - Medical expert witness assessment KW - Pension insurance KW - Accident insurance KW - Symptom validity test KW - Performance validity test ER - TY - JOUR TI - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance AU - Klett, N. AU - Dohrenbusch, R. AU - Siegmann, E.M. AU - Schütz, A. AU - Kornhuber, J. AU - Röhner, J. AU - Keller, F. AU - Capito, E.S. AU - Grömer, T. PY - 2026 JO - Psychological injury and law VL - 19 IS - 2, 19 SP - 1-16 PB - Springer CY - New York, NY SN - 1938-9728 DO - 10.1007/s12207-026-09567-w UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115552 LA - eng AB - Background: Medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs) evaluate case validity on the basis of both psychometric and non-psychometric modalities. Although symptom validity tests (SVTs) and performance validity tests (PVTs) are widely used, many thresholds were developed in analogue and known-groups validation contexts, and their transferability to MEWAs remains uncertain. Prior research validated a Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) as a multimodal framework for assessing case plausibility, but it remained unclear whether CVA and psychometric thresholds perform similarly across different legal contexts, such as pension insurance versus accident insurance evaluations. Objective: This study aimed to investigate differences in CVA, SVT, and PVT results across pension and accident insurance cases. Methods: A total of 721 MEWAs (572 pension; 149 accident) were analyzed. CVA criteria were rated by trained raters, and response biases were assessed psychometrically using the SIMS and the ASTM. Two-component beta-binomial mixture models were applied to derive CVA plausibility thresholds. Results: Mixture modeling reliably identified a distinct bimodal distribution of conspicuous CVA criteria counts, interpreted as plausible and implausible subgroups in both pension and accident cases, with ≥4 conspicuous CVA criteria representing the optimal plausibility threshold. Pension claimants showed significantly higher SIMS scores and lower ASTM scores than accident claimants, independent of case plausibility. Conclusion: CVA can be used to assess validity information collected from multiple data sources (longitudinal and cross-sectional) and to assess the validity of health-related claims across different legal settings. CVA, however, was not a tool for measuring context-specific response biases. Cases with ≤2 conspicuous CVA criteria may be valid, cases with three conspicuous criteria require individual examination because feigning is possible but not certain, and ≥4 conspicuous criteria supported a conservative classification of CVA-defined case implausibility. KW - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment KW - Medical expert witness assessment KW - Pension insurance KW - Accident insurance KW - Symptom validity test KW - Performance validity test ER - TY - JOUR TI - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases of Claimed Reduced Work Capacity AU - Klett, N. AU - Dohrenbusch, R. AU - Fischer, A. AU - Geiger, T. AU - Keller, F. AU - Kornhuber, J. AU - Littke, Ole AU - Schütz, A. AU - Siegmann, E.M. AU - Käfferlein, W. AU - Grömer, T. AU - Capito, E.S. PY - 2026 JO - Psychological Injury and Law VL - 19 IS - 1, 6 SP - 1-11 PB - Springer CY - New York SN - 1938-971X DO - 10.1007/s12207-026-09557-y UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115503 LA - eng AB - Medical Expert Witness Assessments (MEWA) are international standard to generate information involving medical questions in litigations, such as the capacity to work. While this procedure is widely utilized and guidelines for assessing the validity of symptoms using psychometric tools and non-psychometric criteria have been developed, the scientific foundation of this multimodal Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) is weak. This study aims to provide empirical validation of CVA using psychometric Symptom (SVT) and Performance Validity Tests (PVT) as areference point. 466 MEWA conducted in the law of the German Statutory Pension Insurance (GPI), all uniformly having addressed the question of the capacity to work, were analyzed. Information about scores regarding the Structured Inventory of Malingered Symptomatology (SIMS), Amsterdam Short-Term Memory Test (ASTM) aswell as the seven CVA criteria were extracted. A logistic regression using CVA data to group the MEWA into plausible and implausible (over- and/or under reporting of symptoms) cases showed a significant association between implausible cases and SIMS scores (OR= 1. 067; 95%- CI [1.037, 1.098]; p<. 0 01) as well as ASTM scores (OR= 0.965; 95%- CI [0.936, 0.994]; p<.05). In this highly comparable real-world dataset, we find evidence that CVA is indeed a valid tool in terms of convergent validity using a SVT and PVT as the point of reference and provide descriptive data on SVT and PVT that facilitates the interpretation of psychometric test results in such cases. KW - Criteria-Based validity assessment KW - Validation KW - Medical expert witness assessment KW - Pension insurance KW - Symptom validity test KW - Performance validity test ER -