TY - JOUR TI - From a one-dimensional hierarchy to a multidimensional space of scientific english : the relationship between a discipline’s place in the hierarchy of the sciences and its use of grammatical structures AU - Watson, Donald AU - Krug, Manfred AU - Carbon, Claus-Christian PY - 2026 SP - 7227-7249 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberger UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/117555 LA - eng AB - The idea of a Hierarchy of the Sciences (HoS), first proposed by Auguste Comte in the 19th Century, argues that scientific disciplines can be ordered in a hierarchy of complexity, with the inorganic sciences (Astronomy, Physics) being the least complex and the organic sciences (Biology, Sociology) being the most complex. Nearly 200 years later, this order still reflects widely held attitudes towards the relationships between and within academic (sub-) disciplines. HoS-related hypotheses have been supported by a variety of studies using bibliographic, linguistic and scientometric data. The present study investigates whether there is further linguistic, more precisely, grammatical evidence to support or qualify the HoS. We collected a corpus of 39,809 research article abstracts (7,630,993 words) from the Web of Science (WoS) database, performed a multidimensional analysis to identify typical patterns of co-occurring grammatical features and then compared the results of the sub-corpora of the disciplines commonly included in research on the HoS (Arts & Humanities, Sociology, Psychology, Biology, Chemistry, Physics, Astronomy & Astrophysics and Mathematics). Although some of our findings replicated those of previous studies, notably that the grammatically most similar disciplines are those adjacent in traditional arrangements on the HoS, we did not find evidence of a simple one-dimensional hierarchy. Instead, our findings indicate that typical grammatical patterns in the disciplines at the extremes of the traditional hierarchy also resemble one another. This suggests that, as far as grammatical patterns are concerned, representing disciplines in a two-dimensional space of the sciences is superior to a one-dimensional hierarchy. KW - Specificity KW - Discourse community KW - Multidimensional analysis KW - Hierarchy of the sciences KW - Research article KW - Communication KW - Disciplines KW - Scientometrics ER - TY - JOUR TI - From a one-dimensional hierarchy to a multidimensional space of scientific english : the relationship between a discipline’s place in the hierarchy of the sciences and its use of grammatical structures AU - Watson, Donald AU - Krug, Manfred AU - Carbon, Claus-Christian PY - 2026 JO - Scientometrics : an international journal for all quantitative aspects of the science of science, communication in science and science policy VL - 131 IS - 10 SP - 7227-7249 PB - Springer Science + Business Media B.V. CY - Dordrecht [u.a.] SN - 1588-2861 DO - 10.1007/s11192-026-05780-1 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/117554 LA - eng AB - The idea of a Hierarchy of the Sciences (HoS), first proposed by Auguste Comte in the 19th Century, argues that scientific disciplines can be ordered in a hierarchy of complexity, with the inorganic sciences (Astronomy, Physics) being the least complex and the organic sciences (Biology, Sociology) being the most complex. Nearly 200 years later, this order still reflects widely held attitudes towards the relationships between and within academic (sub-) disciplines. HoS-related hypotheses have been supported by a variety of studies using bibliographic, linguistic and scientometric data. The present study investigates whether there is further linguistic, more precisely, grammatical evidence to support or qualify the HoS. We collected a corpus of 39,809 research article abstracts (7,630,993 words) from the Web of Science (WoS) database, performed a multidimensional analysis to identify typical patterns of co-occurring grammatical features and then compared the results of the sub-corpora of the disciplines commonly included in research on the HoS (Arts & Humanities, Sociology, Psychology, Biology, Chemistry, Physics, Astronomy & Astrophysics and Mathematics). Although some of our findings replicated those of previous studies, notably that the grammatically most similar disciplines are those adjacent in traditional arrangements on the HoS, we did not find evidence of a simple one-dimensional hierarchy. Instead, our findings indicate that typical grammatical patterns in the disciplines at the extremes of the traditional hierarchy also resemble one another. This suggests that, as far as grammatical patterns are concerned, representing disciplines in a two-dimensional space of the sciences is superior to a one-dimensional hierarchy. KW - Specificity KW - Discourse community KW - Multidimensional analysis KW - Hierarchy of the sciences KW - Research article KW - Communication KW - Disciplines KW - Scientometrics ER - TY - JOUR TI - The relationship between citations and the linguistic traits of specific academic discourse communities identified by using social network analysis AU - Watson, Donald AU - Krug, Manfred AU - Carbon, Claus-Christian PY - 2022 SP - 1755–1781 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/55963 LA - eng AB - For a research article (RA) to be accepted, not only for publication, but also by its readers, it must display proficiency in the content, methodologies and discourse conventions of its specific discipline. While numerous studies have investigated the linguistic characteristics of different research disciplines, none have utilised Social Network Analysis techniques to identify communities prior to analysing their language use. This study aims to investigate the language use of three highly specific research communities in the fields of Psychology, Physics and Sports Medicine. We were interested in how these language features are related to the total number of citations, the eigencentrality within the community and the intra-network citations of the individual RAs. Applying Biber’s Multidimensional Analysis approach, a total of 771 RA abstracts published between 2010 and 2019 were analysed. We evaluated correlations between one of three network characteristics (citations, eigencentrality and in-degree), the corpora’s dimensions and 72 individual language features. The pattern of correlations suggest that features cited by other RAs within the discourse community network are in almost all cases different from those that are cited by RAs from outside the network. This finding highlights the challenges of writing for both a discipline-specific and a wider audience. KW - Specificity KW - Discourse community KW - Multidimensional analysis KW - Social Network Analysis KW - Research article KW - Communication KW - Dissemination ER - TY - JOUR TI - The relationship between citations and the linguistic traits of specific academic discourse communities identified by using social network analysis AU - Watson, Donald AU - Krug, Manfred AU - Carbon, Claus-Christian PY - 2022 JO - Scientometrics VL - 127 IS - 4 SP - 1755–1781 PB - Springer CY - Dordrecht [u.a.] SN - 1588-2861 DO - 10.1007/s11192-022-04287-9 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/53316 LA - eng AB - For a research article (RA) to be accepted, not only for publication, but also by its readers, it must display proficiency in the content, methodologies and discourse conventions of its specific discipline. While numerous studies have investigated the linguistic characteristics of different research disciplines, none have utilised Social Network Analysis techniques to identify communities prior to analysing their language use. This study aims to investigate the language use of three highly specific research communities in the fields of Psychology, Physics and Sports Medicine. We were interested in how these language features are related to the total number of citations, the eigencentrality within the community and the intra-network citations of the individual RAs. Applying Biber’s Multidimensional Analysis approach, a total of 771 RA abstracts published between 2010 and 2019 were analysed. We evaluated correlations between one of three network characteristics (citations, eigencentrality and in-degree), the corpora’s dimensions and 72 individual language features. The pattern of correlations suggest that features cited by other RAs within the discourse community network are in almost all cases different from those that are cited by RAs from outside the network. This finding highlights the challenges of writing for both a discipline-specific and a wider audience. KW - Specificity KW - Discourse community KW - Multidimensional analysis KW - Social Network Analysis KW - Research article KW - Communication KW - Dissemination ER -