TY - GEN TI - Active Inference in String Diagrams : A Categorical Account of Predictive Processing and Free Energy AU - Tull, Sean AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Smithe, Toby St Clere PY - 2025 SP - 1-41 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/112054 LA - eng AB - We present a categorical formulation of the cognitive frameworks of Predictive Processing and Active Inference, expressed in terms of string diagrams interpreted in a monoidal category with copying and discarding. This includes diagrammatic accounts of generative models, Bayesian updating, perception, planning, active inference, and free energy. In particular we present a diagrammatic derivation of the formula for active inference via free energy minimisation, and establish a compositionality property for free energy, allowing free energy to be applied at all levels of an agent's generative model. Aside from aiming to provide a helpful graphical language for those familiar with active inference, we conversely hope that this article may provide a concise formulation and introduction to the framework. KW - String Diagrams ER - TY - JOUR TI - Towards a structural turn in consciousness science AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - 1-17 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109957 LA - eng AB - Recent activities in virtually all fields engaged in consciousness studies indicate early signs of a structural turn, where verbal descriptions or simple formalisations of conscious experiences are replaced by structural tools, most notably mathematical spaces. My goal here is to offer three comments that, in my opinion, are essential to avoid misunderstandings in these developments early on. These comments concern metaphysical premises of structural approaches, the viability of structure-preserving mappings, and the question of what a structure of conscious experience is in the first place. I will also explain what, in my opinion, are the great promises of structural methodologies and how they might impact consciousness science at large. KW - Quality space KW - Qualia space KW - Phenomenal space KW - Theory of consciousness KW - Structuralism KW - Structure-preserving mapping KW - Isomorphism ER - TY - GEN TI - Defining Biological Naturalism AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-109961 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109961 LA - eng AB - Biological naturalism, as explicated by Seth, is indispensable for a balanced and metaphysically neutral science of AI consciousness. However, most of the properties that Seth explores might not be unique to living systems. Therefore, I argue, a biological naturalist research programme in consciousness science requires an explicit definition of Biological Naturalism. I discuss how such a definition might be obtained. KW - Biological Naturalism KW - Computational Functionalism ER - TY - GEN TI - Mathematical Approaches in the Scientific Study of Consciousness AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - 1-41 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-109959 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109959 LA - eng AB - Mathematical Approaches in the Scientific Study of Consciousness KW - Mathematical Consciousness Science KW - Consciousness Science ER - TY - GEN TI - On the Logic of Measuring Neural Correlates of Consciousness AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - 1-50 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109960 LA - eng AB - This paper presents a mathematical analysis of the logic of measuring Neural Correlates of Consciousness (NCCs). Starting from the canonical definition of NCCs provided by Crick and Koch (1990) and Chalmers (2000), a series of lemmas and theorems are provided which show how NCCs can be discovered if empirical data about the co-activation of neural states and states of consciousness is available. The result of this analysis is a new method to measure NCCs, which we preliminarily call Co-Activation Analysis (CoAA), that might complement or extend existing methods such as contrastive analysis and decoding. CoAA might be of interest for experiments because it does not require data from near-threshold conditions, is compatible with all major conceptions of states of consciousness (including, e.g., micro-phenomenological notions and global states of consciousness), can be applied to most conceptions of neural or computational states (including, e.g., those provided by Predictive Processing/Active Inference, or those attained in more ecological conditions), and helps alleviate the problem of confounders. Furthermore, we show as a theorem that as far as the logic of measurement is concerned, if applied to data from contrastive analysis studies, CoAA improves upon the result provided by contrastive analysis. The paper is a purely theoretical contribution. It is presented in the hope that the mathematics developed here can support and improve the empirical search for NCCs. KW - Neural Correlates of Consciousness KW - Contrastive Analysis ER - TY - GEN TI - The Newman Problem of Consciousness Science AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - 1-17 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109958 LA - eng AB - The Newman problem is a fundamental problem that threatens to undermine structural assumptions and structural theories throughout philosophy and science. Here, we consider the problem in the context of consciousness science. We introduce and discuss the problem, and explain why it is detrimental not only to structuralist assumptions, but also to theories of consciousness, if left unconsidered. However, we show that if phenomenal spaces, and mathematical structures of conscious experience more generally, are understood in the right way, the Newman problem does not arise. The upshot of our paper is that consciousness science needs to be careful in which definition of structure to consider, but if it is, the Newman problem disappears. KW - Newman Problem KW - Consciousness Science KW - Theories of Consciousness KW - Epistemic Phenomenal Structural Realism KW - Ontic Phenomenal Structural Realism ER - TY - JOUR TI - Causal Fermion Systems as an Effective Collapse Theory AU - Finster, Felix AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Paganini, Claudio F. PY - 2025 SP - 1-38 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109954 LA - eng AB - It is shown that, in the non-relativistic limit, causal fermion systems give rise to an effective collapse theory. The nonlinear and stochastic correction terms to the Schrödinger equation are derived from the causal action principle. The dynamics of the statistical operator is described by a deterministic equation of Kossakowski-Lindblad form. Moreover, the quantum state undergoes a dynamical collapse compatible with the Born rule. The effective model has similarities with the continuous spontaneous localization model, but differs from it by a conservation law for the probability integral as well as a non-locality in time on a microscopic length scale \ell_{\min}. KW - Causal fermion systems KW - effective collapse theory ER - TY - JOUR TI - The case for neurons : a no-go theorem for consciousness on a chip AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Ludwig, Tim PY - 2025 SP - 1-11 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109956 LA - eng AB - We apply the methodology of no-go theorems as developed in physics to the question of artificial consciousness. The result is a no-go theorem which shows that under a general assumption, called dynamical relevance, Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems that run on contemporary computer chips cannot be conscious. Consciousness is dynamically relevant, simply put, if, according to a theory of consciousness, it is relevant for the temporal evolution of a system’s states. The no-go theorem rests on facts about semiconductor development: that AI systems run on central processing units, graphics processing units, tensor processing units, or other processors which have been designed and verified to adhere to computational dynamics that systematically preclude or suppress deviations. Whether our result resolves the question of AI consciousness on contemporary processors depends on the truth of the theorem’s main assumption, dynamical relevance, which this paper does not establish. KW - Artificial Consciousness KW - Synthetic Phenomenology KW - Artificial Sentience KW - Machine Consciousness KW - No-Go Theorem KW - Artificial Intelligence KW - Large Language Model ER - TY - JOUR TI - What is a mathematical structure of conscious experience? AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Ludwig, Tim PY - 2025 SP - 1-23 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109955 LA - eng AB - Several promising approaches have been developed to represent conscious experience in terms of mathematical spaces and structures. What is missing, however, is an explicit definition of what a ‘mathematical structure of conscious experience’ is. Here, we propose such a definition. This definition provides a link between the abstract formal entities of mathematics and the concreta of conscious experience; it complements recent approaches that study quality spaces, qualia spaces, or phenomenal spaces; and it provides a general method to identify and investigate structures of conscious experience. We hope that ultimately this work provides a basis for developing a common formal language to study consciousness KW - Quality spaces KW - qualia spaces KW - phenomenal spaces KW - perceptual spaces KW - Q-spaces KW - structuralism ER - TY - GEN TI - On the Logic of Measuring Neural Correlates of Consciousness AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - 1-50 PB - Center for Open Science DO - 10.31234/osf.io/p9ca3_v1 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/110033 LA - eng AB - This paper presents a mathematical analysis of the logic of measuring Neural Correlates of Consciousness (NCCs). Starting from the canonical definition of NCCs provided by Crick and Koch (1990) and Chalmers (2000), a series of lemmas and theorems are provided which show how NCCs can be discovered if empirical data about the co-activation of neural states and states of consciousness is available. The result of this analysis is a new method to measure NCCs, which we preliminarily call Co-Activation Analysis (CoAA), that might complement or extend existing methods such as contrastive analysis and decoding. CoAA might be of interest for experiments because it does not require data from near-threshold conditions, is compatible with all major conceptions of states of consciousness (including, e.g., micro-phenomenological notions and global states of consciousness), can be applied to most conceptions of neural or computational states (including, e.g., those provided by Predictive Processing/Active Inference, or those attained in more ecological conditions), and helps alleviate the problem of confounders. Furthermore, we show as a theorem that as far as the logic of measurement is concerned, if applied to data from contrastive analysis studies, CoAA improves upon the result provided by contrastive analysis. The paper is a purely theoretical contribution. It is presented in the hope that the mathematics developed here can support and improve the empirical search for NCCs. KW - Neural Correlates of Consciousness KW - Contrastive Analysis ER - TY - THES TI - Topics in mathematical consciousness science AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2025 SP - iv, 123 PB - Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität CY - München DO - 10.5282/edoc.35420 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/110031 LA - eng ER - TY - GEN TI - The Newman Problem of Consciousness Science AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2024 SP - 1-17 PB - PhilArchive UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/110032 LA - eng AB - The Newman problem is a fundamental problem that threatens to undermine structural assumptions and structural theories throughout philosophy and science. Here, we consider the problem in the context of consciousness science. We introduce and discuss the problem, and explain why it is detrimental not only to structuralist assumptions, but also to theories of consciousness, if left unconsidered. However, we show that if phenomenal spaces, and mathematical structures of conscious experience more generally, are understood in the right way, the Newman problem does not arise. The upshot of our paper is that consciousness science needs to be careful in which definition of structure to consider, but if it is, the Newman problem disappears. KW - Newman Problem KW - Consciousness Science KW - Theories of Consciousness KW - Epistemic Phenomenal Structural Realism KW - Ontic Phenomenal Structural Realism ER - TY - GEN TI - Consciousness qua Mortal Computation AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2024 PB - arXiv DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2403.03925 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105586 LA - eng ER - TY - JOUR TI - What is a mathematical structure of conscious experience? AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Ludwig, Tim PY - 2024 JO - Synthese : an international journal for epistemology, methodology and philosophy of science VL - 203 IS - 3, 89 SP - 1-23 PB - Springer Science and Business Media LLC CY - Dordrecht [u.a.] SN - 1573-0964 DO - 10.1007/s11229-024-04503-4 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105585 LA - eng AB - Several promising approaches have been developed to represent conscious experience in terms of mathematical spaces and structures. What is missing, however, is an explicit definition of what a ‘mathematical structure of conscious experience’ is. Here, we propose such a definition. This definition provides a link between the abstract formal entities of mathematics and the concreta of conscious experience; it complements recent approaches that study quality spaces, qualia spaces, or phenomenal spaces; and it provides a general method to identify and investigate structures of conscious experience. We hope that ultimately this work provides a basis for developing a common formal language to study consciousness KW - Quality spaces KW - qualia spaces KW - phenomenal spaces KW - perceptual spaces KW - Q-spaces KW - structuralism ER - TY - JOUR TI - Towards a structural turn in consciousness science AU - Kleiner, Johannes PY - 2024 JO - Consciousness and cognition : an international journal VL - 119 IS - 103653 SP - 1-17 PB - Elsevier CY - Amsterdam [u.a.] SN - 1053-8100 DO - 10.1016/j.concog.2024.103653 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105584 LA - eng AB - Recent activities in virtually all fields engaged in consciousness studies indicate early signs of a structural turn, where verbal descriptions or simple formalisations of conscious experiences are replaced by structural tools, most notably mathematical spaces. My goal here is to offer three comments that, in my opinion, are essential to avoid misunderstandings in these developments early on. These comments concern metaphysical premises of structural approaches, the viability of structure-preserving mappings, and the question of what a structure of conscious experience is in the first place. I will also explain what, in my opinion, are the great promises of structural methodologies and how they might impact consciousness science at large. KW - Quality space KW - Qualia space KW - Phenomenal space KW - Theory of consciousness KW - Structuralism KW - Structure-preserving mapping KW - Isomorphism ER - TY - JOUR TI - The case for neurons : a no-go theorem for consciousness on a chip AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Ludwig, Tim PY - 2024 JO - Neuroscience of Consciousness VL - 2024 IS - 1, niae037 SP - 1-11 PB - Oxford University Press CY - Oxford SN - 2057-2107 DO - 10.1093/nc/niae037 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105581 LA - eng AB - We apply the methodology of no-go theorems as developed in physics to the question of artificial consciousness. The result is a no-go theorem which shows that under a general assumption, called dynamical relevance, Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems that run on contemporary computer chips cannot be conscious. Consciousness is dynamically relevant, simply put, if, according to a theory of consciousness, it is relevant for the temporal evolution of a system’s states. The no-go theorem rests on facts about semiconductor development: that AI systems run on central processing units, graphics processing units, tensor processing units, or other processors which have been designed and verified to adhere to computational dynamics that systematically preclude or suppress deviations. Whether our result resolves the question of AI consciousness on contemporary processors depends on the truth of the theorem’s main assumption, dynamical relevance, which this paper does not establish. KW - Artificial Consciousness KW - Synthetic Phenomenology KW - Artificial Sentience KW - Machine Consciousness KW - No-Go Theorem KW - Artificial Intelligence KW - Large Language Model ER - TY - JOUR TI - Causal Fermion Systems as an Effective Collapse Theory AU - Finster, Felix AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Paganini, Claudio F. PY - 2024 JO - Journal of Physics A : Mathematical and Theoretical VL - 57 IS - 39, 395303 PB - IOP Publishing CY - Bristol SN - 1751-8113 DO - 10.1088/1751-8121/ad7655 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105589 LA - eng AB - It is shown that, in the non-relativistic limit, causal fermion systems give rise to an effective collapse theory. The nonlinear and stochastic correction terms to the Schrödinger equation are derived from the causal action principle. The dynamics of the statistical operator is described by a deterministic equation of Kossakowski-Lindblad form. Moreover, the quantum state undergoes a dynamical collapse compatible with the Born rule. The effective model has similarities with the continuous spontaneous localization model, but differs from it by a conservation law for the probability integral as well as a non-locality in time on a microscopic length scale \ell_{\min}. KW - Causal fermion systems KW - effective collapse theory ER - TY - GEN TI - The Closure of the Physical, Consciousness and Scientific Practice AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Hartmann, Stephan PY - 2023 SP - 1-15 PB - arXiv DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2110.03518 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109953 LA - eng ER - TY - GEN TI - Active Inference in String Diagrams : A Categorical Account of Predictive Processing and Free Energy AU - Tull, Sean AU - Kleiner, Johannes AU - Smithe, Toby St Clere PY - 2023 SP - 1-41 PB - arXiv DO - 10.48550/arxiv.2308.00861 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105583 LA - eng AB - We present a categorical formulation of the cognitive frameworks of Predictive Processing and Active Inference, expressed in terms of string diagrams interpreted in a monoidal category with copying and discarding. This includes diagrammatic accounts of generative models, Bayesian updating, perception, planning, active inference, and free energy. In particular we present a diagrammatic derivation of the formula for active inference via free energy minimisation, and establish a compositionality property for free energy, allowing free energy to be applied at all levels of an agent's generative model. Aside from aiming to provide a helpful graphical language for those familiar with active inference, we conversely hope that this article may provide a concise formulation and introduction to the framework. KW - String Diagrams ER -