TY - THES TI - Perspectives on Servant Leadership and Its Associations With Follower Behaviors and Experiences : Three Studies Considering Context and Causality AU - Schowalter, Annika F. PY - 2025 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-109264 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/109264 LA - eng AB - In recent years, there has been increasing interest in the concept of servant leadership, as studies have shown a large variety of positive results. This dissertation aims to enhance the understanding of the relationship between servant leadership and follower behaviors and experiences. To this end, I present three empirical articles that focus on the associations of servant leadership with follower performance and well-being and the methods used to examine the leadership construct as an explanatory variable. Because research on servant leadership has been conducted mostly without contextualization, Studies 1 and 2 explore whether servant leadership is also beneficial in the still underresearched crisis context. Specifically, Study 1 investigates the associations between servant leadership perceptions and followers’ performance (i.e., adaptivity and proactivity) and delves into mediating mechanisms between the constructs. Study 2 takes a dynamic perspective and focuses on the trajectories of and relationship between servant leadership perceptions and follower well-being (i.e., exhaustion) during a crisis. These longitudinal studies have several strengths—however, they should not be causally interpreted. As this is an issue that relates to many studies on servant leadership (and leadership in general), Study 3 deals with the question of whether the effects of servant leadership determined in research so far are robust and what can be done to conduct causally identified studies. Studies 1 and 2 are based on a longitudinal survey among teachers in a German private school association (N = 129) with four measurement points approximately two months apart. Data collection was conducted during the first eight months of the COVID-19 crisis; the first measurement started in March 2020, when the first measures such as curfews were taken. Still, the two studies are independent as they only overlap regarding perceived servant leadership as an explanatory variable. The path model in Study 1 showed that servant leadership perceptions were related to both followers’ adaptivity and proactivity via basic psychological need satisfaction. There were no direct relationships between servant leadership perceptions and follower adaptivity or proactivity, and there was no indirect association with adaptivity via procedural justice. The mediating relationship between servant leadership perceptions and proactivity was negative. The study indicates that followers’ needs should not be overlooked in the crisis context to help them cope with crises and that servant leadership is an appropriate means to achieve this goal. At the same time, Study 1 points to the potential negative effects of servant leadership on proactivity via procedural justice in certain circumstances. Based on conservation of resources theory, Study 2 examined the development of the association between servant leadership perceptions and exhaustion during the first eight months of a crisis. Using latent growth curve modeling, the results showed that servant leadership perceptions were both inter- and intraindividually related to followers’ exhaustion. Between-person, a higher level of servant leadership perceptions was associated with a lower level of exhaustion. Within-person, a greater decrease (increase) in servant leadership perceptions was related to a greater increase (decrease) in exhaustion. Additionally, the univariate trajectories of the constructs yielded that servant leadership perceptions decreased over the study period. The decrease slowed from T1 to T3 before servant leadership perceptions increased again between T3 and T4. Teachers’ exhaustion did not increase on average during the first eight months of the crisis. The trajectories of and associations between the constructs are thus complex and can vary over time. Furthermore, the findings suggest that servant leadership is appropriate for reducing the negative effects of crises on followers’ exhaustion. Study 3 investigated the current state of research regarding causality in the field of servant (and authentic) leadership and provides recommendations on how causally identified studies on these leader behaviors can be conducted to enable researchers to meaningfully inform science and policy. First, endogeneity bias and issues in experimental design are discussed as central problems that can prevent causal inferences from studies on the effects of servant leadership. Then, the current state of research on servant and authentic leadership as explanatory variables is summarized through systematic reviews. The results indicate that the lack of causal examinations is highly prevalent. As guidance in this regard, two ways in which causal research on the effect of servant leadership (perceptions) could be cleanly conducted are described: well-designed randomized experiments and instrumental variable regression. To illustrate the recommendations, an exemplary experiment was conducted using manipulated leader behavior as an instrument for follower perceptions. In this randomized lab experiment, the effect of a combined stewardship and authenticity manipulation, as well as the perceptions thereof, on individual task performance were examined. The experiment did not reveal an effect of either combined stewardship and authenticity behavior or perceptions thereof on performance. In summary, this dissertation provides first evidence that servant leadership can be beneficial in the crisis context but that it can also have unintended negative effects. Additionally, pitfalls in servant leadership research that severely limit the validity of empirical studies in the field are pointed out. To support the conduction of solid, causally identified research, recommendations to improve research are provided, along with an illustrative experiment. In this way, this dissertation contributes to the state of research on servant leadership in context and over time as well as on its associations with follower performance and well-being and the potential underlying mediating mechanisms of these relationships. Additionally, the presented roadmap can help advance research on servant leadership with robust studies. KW - servant leadership KW - crisis KW - performance KW - basic psychological need satisfaction KW - procedural justice KW - exhaustion KW - conservation of resources theory KW - latent growth curve modeling KW - COVID-19 KW - authentic leadership KW - systematic review KW - experiment KW - instrumental variable estimation KW - context KW - causality ER - TY - JOUR TI - Trajectories and Associations of Perceived Servant Leadership and Teacher Exhaustion During the First Months of a Crisis AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2025 SP - 57-88 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/107105 LA - eng AB - Organizational crises carry a high risk of reducing well-being and health among employees, such as increased exhaustion. Teachers are particularly vulnerable to exhaustion; thus, it is important to explore how exhaustion can be reduced among them in a crisis context. In this paper, we regard servant leadership as a resource-providing leadership style to mitigate the adverse impacts of a crisis situation on teachers’ exhaustion. We surveyed 129 teachers working at several schools in a German private school association at four measurement points between March and November 2020, beginning with the first measures taken in response to the spread of COVID-19. Using latent growth curve modeling, we investigated the trajectories of perceived servant leadership and employees’ exhaustion and their associations. For both teacher exhaustion and servant leadership, growth models with unspecified growth patterns showed the best fit. Perceived servant leadership decreased over time before increasing slightly again during the last measurement period. We did not find a general increase in teacher exhaustion. Consistent with our hypotheses, the results indicated a negative interindividual and intraindividual association between servant leadership and teacher exhaustion. Teachers who perceived higher levels of servant leadership reported lower levels of exhaustion, and the stronger servant leadership decreased, the stronger exhaustion increased over time. Our study extends previous research by providing a dynamic, longitudinal view of servant leadership and exhaustion in a crisis context. KW - Servant leadership KW - Exhaustion KW - Crisis KW - Conservation of resources theory KW - Latent growth curve modeling KW - COVID-19 ER - TY - JOUR TI - Servant and Crisis Manager? : The Association of Servant Leadership with Followers’ Adaptivity and Proactivity AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2025 SP - 433-452 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/105935 LA - eng AB - Crisis situations require employees to be adaptive and proactive in order to be successfully managed. Because servant leaders focus on serving their followers, they should be able to fulfill their followers’ needs and respond appropriately to situations that cause uncertainty, thereby helping them manage crises. Against this backdrop, we investigated whether the perception of servant leadership can support follower adaptivity and proactivity in a crisis context. Additionally, we examined two potential mediating processes to explain these relationships (i.e., followers’ basic psychological need satisfaction and procedural justice perceptions). Using a longitudinal study with three measurement points between March 2020 (at the beginning of the COVID-19 crisis) and October 2020, we surveyed 129 teachers employed at several schools in a private school association in Germany. In line with our hypotheses, the results of the path analysis showed that servant leadership perceptions were positively associated with both mediators. The relationships between servant leadership and followers’ proactivity and adaptivity were mediated by basic need satisfaction. However, contrary to our assumptions, we found no direct associations between servant leadership and follower behavior, no indirect relationship between servant leadership and adaptivity via procedural justice, and even a negative indirect relationship between servant leadership and proactive behavior via procedural justice. Based on our findings, we discuss the potential benefits and negative implications of servant leadership in the crisis context. KW - crisis KW - servant leadership KW - performance KW - basic psychological need satisfaction KW - procedural justice ER - TY - JOUR TI - Trajectories and Associations of Perceived Servant Leadership and Teacher Exhaustion During the First Months of a Crisis AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2025 JO - Occupational Health Science VL - 9 IS - 1 SP - 57-88 PB - Springer Science and Business Media LLC CY - Cham SN - 2367-0142 DO - 10.1007/s41542-024-00206-x UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/97886 LA - eng AB - Organizational crises carry a high risk of reducing well-being and health among employees, such as increased exhaustion. Teachers are particularly vulnerable to exhaustion; thus, it is important to explore how exhaustion can be reduced among them in a crisis context. In this paper, we regard servant leadership as a resource-providing leadership style to mitigate the adverse impacts of a crisis situation on teachers’ exhaustion. We surveyed 129 teachers working at several schools in a German private school association at four measurement points between March and November 2020, beginning with the first measures taken in response to the spread of COVID-19. Using latent growth curve modeling, we investigated the trajectories of perceived servant leadership and employees’ exhaustion and their associations. For both teacher exhaustion and servant leadership, growth models with unspecified growth patterns showed the best fit. Perceived servant leadership decreased over time before increasing slightly again during the last measurement period. We did not find a general increase in teacher exhaustion. Consistent with our hypotheses, the results indicated a negative interindividual and intraindividual association between servant leadership and teacher exhaustion. Teachers who perceived higher levels of servant leadership reported lower levels of exhaustion, and the stronger servant leadership decreased, the stronger exhaustion increased over time. Our study extends previous research by providing a dynamic, longitudinal view of servant leadership and exhaustion in a crisis context. KW - Servant leadership KW - Exhaustion KW - Crisis KW - Conservation of resources theory KW - Latent growth curve modeling KW - COVID-19 ER - TY - JOUR TI - Servant and Crisis Manager? : The Association of Servant Leadership with Followers’ Adaptivity and Proactivity AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2024 JO - Journal of leadership & organizational studies : JLOS VL - 31 IS - 4 SP - 433-452 PB - Sage CY - Thousand Oaks, Calif. SN - 1939-7089 DO - 10.1177/15480518241287647 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/98549 LA - eng AB - Crisis situations require employees to be adaptive and proactive in order to be successfully managed. Because servant leaders focus on serving their followers, they should be able to fulfill their followers’ needs and respond appropriately to situations that cause uncertainty, thereby helping them manage crises. Against this backdrop, we investigated whether the perception of servant leadership can support follower adaptivity and proactivity in a crisis context. Additionally, we examined two potential mediating processes to explain these relationships (i.e., followers’ basic psychological need satisfaction and procedural justice perceptions). Using a longitudinal study with three measurement points between March 2020 (at the beginning of the COVID-19 crisis) and October 2020, we surveyed 129 teachers employed at several schools in a private school association in Germany. In line with our hypotheses, the results of the path analysis showed that servant leadership perceptions were positively associated with both mediators. The relationships between servant leadership and followers’ proactivity and adaptivity were mediated by basic need satisfaction. However, contrary to our assumptions, we found no direct associations between servant leadership and follower behavior, no indirect relationship between servant leadership and adaptivity via procedural justice, and even a negative indirect relationship between servant leadership and proactive behavior via procedural justice. Based on our findings, we discuss the potential benefits and negative implications of servant leadership in the crisis context. KW - crisis KW - servant leadership KW - performance KW - basic psychological need satisfaction KW - procedural justice ER - TY - JOUR TI - Are the effects of servant leadership only spurious? : the state of research on the causal effects of servant leadership, recommendations, and an illustrative experiment AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2023 JO - The leadership quarterly : an international journal of political, social and behavioral science VL - 34 IS - 6, 101722 SP - 1-22 PB - Elsevier BV CY - Amsterdam SN - 1048-9843 DO - 10.1016/j.leaqua.2023.101722 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/91677 LA - eng ER - TY - JOUR TI - Developing Sustainable Careers during a Pandemic : The Role of Psychological Capital and Career Adaptability AU - Zyberaj, Jetmir AU - Seibel, Sebastian AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Pötz, Lennart AU - Richter-Killenberg, Stefanie AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2022 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/53530 LA - eng AB - The Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has not only had negative effects on employees’ health, but also on their prospects to gain and maintain employment. Using a longitudinal research design with two measurement points, we investigated the ramifications of various psychological and organizational resources on employees’ careers during the COVID-19 pandemic. Specifically, in a sample of German employees (N = 305), we investigated the role of psychological capital (PsyCap) for four career-related outcomes: career satisfaction, career engagement, coping with changes in career due to COVID-19, and career-related COVID-19 worries. We also employed leader–member exchange (LMX) as a moderator and career adaptability as a mediating variable in these relationships. Results from path analyses revealed a positive association between PsyCap and career satisfaction and career coping. Furthermore, PsyCap was indirectly related to career engagement through career adaptability. However, moderation analysis showed no moderating role of LMX on the link between PsyCap and career adaptability. Our study contributes to the systematic research concerning the role of psychological and organizational resources for employees’ careers and well-being, especially for crisis contexts. KW - psychological capital; career adaptability; LMX; career engagement; career satisfaction; career coping; COVID-19 ER - TY - JOUR TI - Developing Sustainable Careers during a Pandemic : The Role of Psychological Capital and Career Adaptability AU - Zyberaj, Jetmir AU - Seibel, Sebastian AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Pötz, Lennart AU - Richter-Killenberg, Stefanie AU - Volmer, Judith PY - 2022 JO - Sustainability VL - 14 IS - 5 SP - 1-17 PB - Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI) CY - Basel SN - 2071-1050 DO - 10.3390/su14053105 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/53769 LA - eng AB - The Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) has not only had negative effects on employees’ health, but also on their prospects to gain and maintain employment. Using a longitudinal research design with two measurement points, we investigated the ramifications of various psychological and organizational resources on employees’ careers during the COVID-19 pandemic. Specifically, in a sample of German employees (N = 305), we investigated the role of psychological capital (PsyCap) for four career-related outcomes: career satisfaction, career engagement, coping with changes in career due to COVID-19, and career-related COVID-19 worries. We also employed leader–member exchange (LMX) as a moderator and career adaptability as a mediating variable in these relationships. Results from path analyses revealed a positive association between PsyCap and career satisfaction and career coping. Furthermore, PsyCap was indirectly related to career engagement through career adaptability. However, moderation analysis showed no moderating role of LMX on the link between PsyCap and career adaptability. Our study contributes to the systematic research concerning the role of psychological and organizational resources for employees’ careers and well-being, especially for crisis contexts. KW - psychological capital; career adaptability; LMX; career engagement; career satisfaction; career coping; COVID-19 ER - TY - CPAPER TI - The Effect of Affective and Cognitive Reactions on Change Readiness over Time AU - Schüßlbauer, Annika AU - Kohnke, Oliver AU - Burger, Axel M. PY - 2021 SP - 1-28 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-51196 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/51196 LA - eng AB - We examined how change management interventions influence employees’ affective and (abstract versus concrete) cognitive reactions and how these reactions are in turn associated with change readiness. In addition, we analyzed whether the association of change readiness with these reactions varies depending on the temporal distance to the implementation of a change. Findings provide evidence for the assumed mediation models but not for the moderating role of temporal distance. KW - change readiness KW - construal level theory KW - feelings-as-information theory ER - TY - CPAPER TI - The Effect of Affective and Cognitive Reactions on Change Readiness over Time AU - Schowalter, Annika AU - Kohnke, Oliver AU - Burger, Axel M. PY - 2020 SP - 1-28 ; Poster PB - Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology CY - Bowling Green (Ohio), USA UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/54045 LA - eng AB - We examined how change management interventions influence employees’ affective and (abstract versus concrete) cognitive reactions and how these reactions are in turn associated with change readiness. In addition, we analyzed whether the association of change readiness with these reactions varies depending on the temporal distance to the implementation of a change. Findings provide evidence for the assumed mediation models but not for the moderating role of temporal distance. KW - change readiness KW - construal level theory KW - feelings-as-information theory ER - TY - JOUR TI - The Goal Paves the Way: Inspirational Motivation as a Predictor of Career Adaptability AU - Schüßlbauer, Annika F. AU - Volmer, Judith AU - Göritz, Anja S. PY - 2017 JO - Journal of Career Development PB - Sage Publ. CY - Thousand Oaks, Calif [u.a.] SN - 0894-8453 DO - 10.1177/0894845317718348 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/42560 LA - eng AB - To cope with a changing work world, organizations look for job applicants who rate high on career adaptability. The present study investigates whether leadership influences employees’ career adapt- ability. Specifically, we investigated whether inspirational motivation fosters career adaptability and whether employees’ future temporal focus mediates this impact. With a time lag of 3 months, 766 employees working in various branches answered two questionnaires. Inspirational motivation by their leaders predicted employee career adaptability, mediated by employee future temporal focus. Findings yield implications for personnel recruitment and development. KW - inspirational motivation, career adaptability, future temporal focus ER -