TY - THES TI - Cities in Transition : Institutional Breaches and Governance Transformations AU - Ramkumar, Raghuveer PY - 2025 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-112014 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/112014 LA - eng AB - Cities are transitioning – transitioning from being mere delivery vehicles for national policies to creators and implementors of their own context-specific policies, from adhering to national guidelines to aligning to local needs, from being static spatial entities to becoming dynamic actors in the delivery of international goals. This transition is real and is happening now. This transition is not sudden and the signs of it have been visible in the past decade, around the world. This is becoming increasingly pronounced of late given the pace and nature of the challenges that the world is having to deal with – effects of climate change, exploitation of natural resources to cater to the increasing needs of the populace, loss of biodiversity, need for reducing social inequality, and the list goes on. The negative effects of these challenges are experienced the most at the ground-level – in cities and towns. In this research, I have studied this significant evolution in the city scape through the lens of Institutional Theory. There are several research papers that have studied cities through the urban and place-making lens, and likewise, there are many papers on institutional theories that focused on organisations, or industries. There is very little evidence of any research that brings these two areas together – Institutional theory in the context of cities. More specifically, I refer to the streams of Institutional Breaches and Institutional Governance and draw parallels to how cities are breaching international and national policies for the benefit of their own communities and how they are developing tailored governance mechanisms to deliver on the local agendas. I gather observations from three different institutional fields – economic growth and regeneration, energy transition and climate resilience, and implementation of the sustainable development goals. Across these three institutional fields, I have gathered evidence from cities to understand how they have breached conventional policy norms, the characteristics of these breaches, and the complementary governance frameworks that they have created to deliver on the new institutional logics. The findings show that the triggers for these breaches are usually one or more of – contextual pressures, infrastructure void, aspirational shortfall, or stakeholder expectations. These breaches are essentially rooted, targeted, and/or relational in nature. The governance mechanisms they design are collaborative, incentivised, or adaptive in how they manifest themselves through the associated norms and practices. Situated Breaches and Situated Governance Mechanisms is the terminology I use to refer to these kinds of breaches and the associated governance mechanisms – ‘situated’ in the context of the needs of the city and the dynamics of the institutional field. These ‘situated’ breaches are different to the presently known types of institutional breaches – collision, hybrid, severe, etc., owing to the nature of the trigger and the intended purpose of the breach. Most importantly, these breaches don’t result in institutional level repair to revert to a stable state, rather these signify a new pathway for institutional evolution. Likewise, situated governance mechanisms differ from the presently known types of institutional governance – performative, normative, negotiated, owing to the collaborative, incentivised, and adaptive nature of these mechanisms. These concepts provide a new dimension to the streams of institutional breaches and institutional governance and more so in the context of cities. The contribution of this research to the field of institutional theory creates scope for future work especially in the light of current events happening around the world – geo-political tensions, natural disasters, emergencies, and the many more occurrences that are impacting humanity. Cities are ‘situating’ themselves in the light of worldly events to ensure that they are doing the right thing for their people and places rather than just doing things right. They are transitioning and in the process are breaching conventional policies and norms and are transforming how they are structured and organised to deliver for their respective cities. It is not a one-off but a movement that is gaining momentum and voice. This is fuelled by numerous entities and organisations that are absolutely backing this move not as a show of political prowess but as an absolute necessity as we all work towards making this planet safe, secure, and resilient for us and for the coming generations to thrive. KW - Institutional Breaches KW - Institutional Governance KW - Institutional Theory KW - Institutional Infrastructure KW - Situated Breaches KW - Situated Governance KW - City Governance KW - Contemporary Challenges KW - Contextual Pressures KW - Stakeholder Expectations KW - Aspirational Shortfall KW - Infrastructure Void ER - TY - THES TI - Rethinking Participation in Strategy and Innovation : Attention- and Practice-Based Perspectives AU - Brielmaier, Christoph PY - 2025 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-108583 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/108583 LA - eng AB - This doctoral thesis focuses on a critical yet often taken for granted phenomenon in management research: participation, i.e. actors’ (voluntary) involvement in organizational and strategic processes. Prior research has largely converged on the benefits of participation for organizations, such as enabling strategic renewal, facilitating the development of superior strategies, and enhancing innovation outcomes by harnessing the wisdom of the many. More recently, we have seen the rise of open forms of strategizing and innovating, which fundamentally revolve around participation. For instance, firms increasingly employ what came to be called Open Strategy, including actors beyond top managers to contribute to the strategy process. Despite the importance of voluntary participation in such initiatives, it has widely remained an implicit and taken for granted phenomenon in the literature without being explicitly theorized. This doctoral thesis builds upon the attention-based view of the firm (ABV) and practice-theoretical perspectives to develop novel theoretical insights into voluntary participation in organizations. It consists of five papers employing review, conceptual, qualitative, and quantitative approaches: Paper I is a literature review of the ABV, providing the foundation for the subsequent papers. Paper II draws on the ABV to theorize (non-) participation in Open Strategy as the result of ‘attention contests’. It is grounded in the observation that, although firms invite the crowd of employees to participate, only a small fraction ultimately chooses to do so. Paper III focuses on voluntary participation in strategy work with important implications for open strategy and strategy-as-practice. The conceptual paper draws upon practice theory in order to develop a process model of voluntary participation as an ongoing accomplishment. Paper IV is a qualitative paper that explores (non-)participation choices in an internal innovation contest through an ABV and sensemaking lens. Internal innovation contests typically present incoherent attention structural conditions: They encourage participation while simultaneously requiring employees to sustain attention to their regular work. The paper theorizes participation in corporate innovation as the interplay of incoherent attention structures and sensemaking practices. Paper V takes another perspective on participation, focusing on the effects of participation in social media on managers. Using an experimental approach, it demonstrates that exposure to strategic conversations on social media significantly influences managers’ strategic preferences. The paper stresses social media participation as a powerful means of shaping strategies from outside a firm’s boundaries. Each of the papers makes several theoretical contributions to distinct literatures, while offering important practical implications. For instance, the thesis highlights that inviting the crowd to participate in strategy and innovation does not automatically result in diverse participation, as tacit structural constraints may exclude particular actors. The doctoral thesis concludes with broader reflections on the potential and limits of voluntary participation in organizations. KW - Participation KW - Attention-Based-View of the Firm KW - Strategy-as-Practice KW - Practice Theory KW - Inclusion KW - Open Strategy ER - TY - THES TI - Strategic Change as a Process of Meaning Making : Empirical Studies on Sensemaking, Role Identity, and Accountability Enactment in Situations of Strategic Change AU - Konuk, Vivienne PY - 2023 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-92544 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/92544 LA - eng AB - This thesis explores strategic change as a process of meaning making. Most of the literature on strategic change has previously considered organisational actors either as recipients or enactors of change. As strategic change typically acts as a trigger of meaning void, it requires organisational actors to revise their interpretation of organisational reality, all while being engaged in strategizing activities. Arguing that strategic change has to be understood as part received, part enacted when investigating the notion of meaning, this dissertation aims to contribute to the overarching research question of “How do organisational actors respond to ambiguous meanings while enacting strategic change?”. This thesis consists of three empirical papers building on the theoretical lenses of sensemaking, role identity, and accountability. I demonstrate the importance of enactment for organisational actors in order to create new meaning of organisational reality and to be able to prospectively make sense of and commit to strategic change. I further show how the enactment of managerial role identity influences managerial intentions, and thus strategic change. Finally, I demonstrate how middle managers enact accountability and shape their roles in change-related ambiguous environments, which determines their contribution to strategic change. Each paper of this dissertation, each with its own theoretical contributions, demonstrates the simultaneity of change reception and enactment, as strategic change is a process of meaning making. KW - Strategic Change KW - Meaning Making KW - Sensemaking KW - Role Identity KW - Accountability ER - TY - THES TI - The Digital Transformation of Incumbent Firms AU - Hanel, Erik PY - 2023 PB - Otto-Friedrich-Universität CY - Bamberg DO - 10.20378/irb-91015 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/91015 LA - eng AB - Digital capability gaps in traditional industries: Influencing factors and strategic responses This paper introduces the concept of digital capability gaps (DCG); the relative difference of a focal firm’s ability to design and control products, services, and processes by utilizing digital technologies in relation to customers. These capability differences matter as they affect incumbents’ strategic response and the value-creating relationship between firms and customers. First, our findings reveal that strategic responses differ according to the magnitude of DCGs: Large DCGs may offer the opportunity for ‘digital diversification’ by using the capabilities developed to enter new domains. In cases of moderate DCGs, firms aim to bridge gaps by adopting the role of a ‘digital parent’ and innovate on behalf of customers. Finally, in the cases of small DCGs firms may respond by forming ‘digital collaborations’ in order to jointly develop digital capabilities. Second, our study also unpacks the influencing factors that affect DCGs: the consolidation or fragmentation of customer portfolio and competitive landscape and the extent to which players have a similar digital pressure for adopting digital capabilities. Overall, our study contributes to the growing literature on the digital transformation of incumbents. KW - digital transformation KW - digital capabilities KW - incumbent firms ER -