TY - CHAP TI - Comparing Standard Reference Corpora and Google Books Ngrams : Strengths, Limitations and Synergies in the Contrastive Study of Variable h- in British and American English AU - Sönning, Lukas AU - Schlüter, Julia PY - 2022 T2 - Data and Methods in Corpus Linguistics : Comparative Approaches SP - 17-45 PB - Cambridge University Press CY - Cambridge ; New York SN - 9781108499644 DO - 10.1017/9781108589314.002 UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/54064 LA - eng AB - This chapter is based on two standard reference corpora, the British National Corpus and the Corpus of Contemporary American English, as opposed to the multi-billion-word database of Google Books Ngrams, which has, despite its allure, not been used in many systematic linguistic studies so far. Focusing on indefinite article allomorphy (a vs an) as an orthographic cue to the phonological strength of ‹h›-onsets in British and American English, the size advantage of the Ngrams database expectedly plays out in larger type and token counts, more stable estimates and fewer distortions due to data sparsity. However, as metadata are extremely limited (to year and variety), a fully accountable analysis is not feasible. The case study illustrates how richly annotated corpora can shed light on potential disturbances arising from two sources: genre differences and between-author variability. A sensitivity analysis offers some degree of reassurance when extending the analysis to the Ngrams database. In this way, the authors demonstrate that the strengths and limitations of corpora and big data resources can, with due caution, be counterbalanced to answer questions of linguistic interest. KW - Google Books Ngrams KW - big data KW - metadata KW - type frequency KW - token frequency KW - hierarchical data structure KW - corpus comparability KW - data quality ER -