TY - JOUR TI - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance AU - Klett, N. AU - Dohrenbusch, R. AU - Siegmann, E.M. AU - Schütz, A. AU - Kornhuber, J. AU - Röhner, J. AU - Keller, F. AU - Capito, E.S. AU - Grömer, T. PY - 2026 JO - Psychological injury and law VL - 19 IS - 2, 19 SP - 1-16 PB - Springer CY - New York, NY SN - 1938-9728 DO - 10.1007/s12207-026-09567-w UR - https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115552 LA - eng AB - Background: Medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs) evaluate case validity on the basis of both psychometric and non-psychometric modalities. Although symptom validity tests (SVTs) and performance validity tests (PVTs) are widely used, many thresholds were developed in analogue and known-groups validation contexts, and their transferability to MEWAs remains uncertain. Prior research validated a Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) as a multimodal framework for assessing case plausibility, but it remained unclear whether CVA and psychometric thresholds perform similarly across different legal contexts, such as pension insurance versus accident insurance evaluations. Objective: This study aimed to investigate differences in CVA, SVT, and PVT results across pension and accident insurance cases. Methods: A total of 721 MEWAs (572 pension; 149 accident) were analyzed. CVA criteria were rated by trained raters, and response biases were assessed psychometrically using the SIMS and the ASTM. Two-component beta-binomial mixture models were applied to derive CVA plausibility thresholds. Results: Mixture modeling reliably identified a distinct bimodal distribution of conspicuous CVA criteria counts, interpreted as plausible and implausible subgroups in both pension and accident cases, with ≥4 conspicuous CVA criteria representing the optimal plausibility threshold. Pension claimants showed significantly higher SIMS scores and lower ASTM scores than accident claimants, independent of case plausibility. Conclusion: CVA can be used to assess validity information collected from multiple data sources (longitudinal and cross-sectional) and to assess the validity of health-related claims across different legal settings. CVA, however, was not a tool for measuring context-specific response biases. Cases with ≤2 conspicuous CVA criteria may be valid, cases with three conspicuous criteria require individual examination because feigning is possible but not certain, and ≥4 conspicuous criteria supported a conservative classification of CVA-defined case implausibility. KW - Criteria-Based Validity Assessment KW - Medical expert witness assessment KW - Pension insurance KW - Accident insurance KW - Symptom validity test KW - Performance validity test ER -