@phdthesis{schimanke2022_55317,
  title = {The Effect of using Spaced Repetition in Mobile Learning Games on the Learning Success},
  author = {Schimanke, Florian},
  year = {2022},
  publisher = {Otto-Friedrich-Universität},
  address = {Bamberg},
  doi = {10.20378/irb-55317},
  urn = {urn:nbn:de:bvb:473-irb-553175},
  url = {https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/55317},
  language = {eng},
  abstract = {The field of learning has been researched in multiple ways and directions. The different learning strategies of individual learners represent one of those fields. Especially in traditional learning environments, such as school or university, learners tend to result-driven learning strategies like massing and cramming, which foremost aim at using the short-term memory to have the necessary information available during a test or an exam. An approach that focuses more on the long-term is called “spacing” and uses sophistically determined intervals between learning sessions that are unique to each learner and are proven to have a positive effect on the sustainable retention of knowledge. However, since spaced repetition is still a repetition-based learning strategy, it is prone to bore the learners by requiring them to repeat the same action over and over again.

One approach to take the boredom out of repetition-based learning is gamification or game-based learning. Using learning games can lead to a higher motivation and thus to a higher probability that the learners continue to use the game and keep on learning through it. Current technologies like smartphones and tablets are capable of handling sophisticated learning games, offer the possibility to use them ubiquitously and therefore act as a facilitator for a learning on demand.

While spaced repetition is not a new field of research, the effect of this learning approach on the learning success has not yet been researched when being used in combination with a mobile learning game. Combining the motivating effect of ubiquitous game-based learning with spaced repetition seems to be a promising combination for an improved learning success. The aim of the presented research is to investigate if using spaced repetition in a mobile learning game leads indeed to the desired success.

To do so, several aspects were considered, including how the SM2 spaced repetition algorithm can be integrated into a mobile learning game, the negative effect that too much motivation can have, how to deal with early and late repetitions, how to conclude automated tests of the implementation, how to collect and filter real-world data to analyze the effectiveness, and how learning analytics can be applied to this analysis. For the data collection, an algorithmic framework, containing the SM2 and the self-developed FS algorithm was integrated into an established geography learning game. The collected data was then filtered and analyzed in accordance with an established definition for learning success. For this, a test group with players who played at least one category from the learning game strictly according to the spaced repetition approach and a control group with players who played the game at more or less random times were built from the collected data. Their progress throughout the observation period was compared and a conclusion was drawn from this.

The two main indicators for the effect on the learning success were defined as the “Average Base Knowledge” (ABK) and the “Average Retention Score” (ARS). The ABK is the average number of correct answers during the first game in both groups, while the ARS is the average correctness during the so-called "leaerning-games", which are the games from the 3rd to the nth game. While both groups started with a comparable ABK of 0.5, the test group already achieved an almost perfect ARS for the fourth game (i.e. the third repetition) of 0.95. The control group on the other hand reached an ARS of 0.63 for the same repetition without the interval calculation by the SM2 algorithm. This effect continues during the following repetitions, during which the ARS for the test group stayed between 0.98 and 1.0, while the control group reaches a maximum ARS of 0.87 after 14 games, which marked the end of the observation period. Further structure exploratory analyses, such as a cluster analysis and a logistic regression confirmed the findings from the comparison of the development of the ABK and the ARS.

Summarized, the analyses showed that there is a considerable difference between the two groups. Foremost, while the retention improved in both groups, the test group achieved a quicker improvement and a lasting retention of knowledge over time, which is matches exactly the definition that was established for learning success in the presented research.},
  keywords = {spaced repetition, game-based learning, learning strategies, learning analytics},
  school = {Otto-Friedrich-Universität Bamberg}
}
