Automatic Analysis of Political Debates and Manifestos : Successes and Challenges
Ceron, Tanise; Barić, Ana; Blessing, André; u. a. (2024): Automatic Analysis of Political Debates and Manifestos : Successes and Challenges, in: Philipp Cimiano, Anette Frank, Michael Kohlhase, u. a. (Hrsg.), Robust argumentation machines : first international conference, RATIO 2024, Bielefeld, Germany, June 5-7, 2024 : proceedings, Cham, Switzerland: Springer Nature, S. 71–88, doi: 10.1007/978-3-031-63536-6_5.
Details
- Faculty/Chair
- Faculty/Professorship
- Author
- Ceron, Tanise; Barić, Ana; Blessing, André; Haunss, Sebastian; Kuhn, Jonas; Lapesa, Gabriella; Padó, Sebastian;
Papay, Sean; Zauchner, Patricia F.
- Title of the compilation
- Robust argumentation machines : first international conference, RATIO 2024, Bielefeld, Germany, June 5-7, 2024 : proceedings
- Editors
- Cimiano, PhilippFrank, AnetteKohlhase, MichaelStein, Benno
- Conference
- Robust Argumentation Machines (RATIO 2024), Bielefeld, Germany
- Publisher Information
- Springer Nature : Cham, Switzerland
- Year of publication
- 2024
- ISBN
- 978-3-031-63536-6
- Language
- English
- DOI
- URL
- Abstract
The opinions of political actors (e.g., politicians, parties, organizations) expressed through claims are the core elements of political debates and decision-making. Political actors communicate through different channels: parties publish manifestos for major elections, while individual actors make statements on a day-to-day basis as reflected in the media. These two channels offer different approaches for analysis: Manifestos, on the one hand, are useful to characterize the parties’ positions at a global ideological level over time. In contrast, individual statements can be collected to analyze debates in particular policy domains on a fine-grained level, in terms of individual actors and claims. In this article, we summarize a series of studies we have carried out. We apply NLP-driven (semi-)automatic analyses on these two channels and compare their potentials and challenges. The fine-grained analysis yields rich insights into the communication but comes at the cost of three challenges: (a) a substantial hunger for manual annotation, introducing practical hurdles for analysis both within and across languages; (b) difficulties in claim classification arising from the uneven frequency distribution over the theory-based annotation schemas; (c) the need to map actor mentions onto canonical versions. Manifesto-based analysis avoids these challenges to a substantial extent when a more coarse-grained analysis of party positions is sufficient. We highlight the benefits and challenges of both approaches, and conclude by outlining perspectives for addressing the challenges in future research.
- Keywords
- Claim identificationdiscourse network analysisparty positioningargument mining
- Type
- Conferenceobject
- URI
- Activation date
- 2026-05-28