Skip to content

Read-only version: For security reasons, the Research Information System (FIS) has been temporarily replaced by this read-only version. All public content and full texts remain available; login, editing, submission and statistics are not available. Questions: fis@uni-bamberg.de

Home › Publications › Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches to Generalization and Replication : A Representationalist View

Publication

Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches to Generalization and Replication : A Representationalist View

Borgstede, Matthias; Scholz, Marcel (2021): Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches to Generalization and Replication : A Representationalist View, in: Bamberg: Otto-Friedrich-Universität, S. 1–9, doi: 10.20378/irb-49473.

Details

Faculty/Chair
Faculty/Professorship
Author
Publisher Information
Otto-Friedrich-Universität : Bamberg
Year of publication
2021
Source/Other editions
Frontiers in psychology, 12 (2021) 605191, S. 1-9.
Language
English
DOI
Licence
URN
Abstract

In this paper, we provide a re-interpretation of qualitative and quantitative modeling from a representationalist perspective. In this view, both approaches attempt to construct abstract representations of empirical relational structures. Whereas quantitative research uses variable-based models that abstract from individual cases, qualitative research favors case-based models that abstract from individual characteristics. Variable-based models are usually stated in the form of quantified sentences (scientific laws). This syntactic structure implies that sentences about individual cases are derived using deductive reasoning. In contrast, case-based models are usually stated using context-dependent existential sentences (qualitative statements). This syntactic structure implies that sentences about other cases are justifiable by inductive reasoning. We apply this representationalist perspective to the problems of generalization and replication. Using the analytical framework of modal logic, we argue that the modes of reasoning are often not only applied to the context that has been studied empirically, but also on a between-contexts level. Consequently, quantitative researchers mostly adhere to a top-down strategy of generalization, whereas qualitative researchers usually follow a bottom-up strategy of generalization. Depending on which strategy is employed, the role of replication attempts is very different. In deductive reasoning, replication attempts serve as empirical tests of the underlying theory. Therefore, failed replications imply a faulty theory. From an inductive perspective, however, replication attempts serve to explore the scope of the theory. Consequently, failed replications do not question the theory per se, but help to shape its boundary conditions. We conclude that quantitative research may benefit from a bottom-up generalization strategy as it is employed in most qualitative research programs. Inductive reasoning forces us to think about the boundary conditions of our theories and provides a framework for generalization beyond statistical testing. In this perspective, failed replications are just as informative as successful replications, because they help to explore the scope of our theories.

GND Keywords
Forschung
Qualitative Methode
Quantitative Methode
Modallogik
Homomorphe Replikation
Generalisierung
Keywords
qualitative research, representational measurement, research methodology, modal logic, generalizability, replication crisis
DDC Classification
150 Psychology
RVK Classification
CM 3600
Peer Reviewed
yes
International Distribution
yes
Open Access Journal
yes
Type
Article
URI
Activation date
2021-02-12

Permalink: https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/49473 · Data as JSON · Cite: BibTeX · RIS

Data as of: 2026-11-16

Restricted read-only access: login, editing and submission are temporarily disabled.