Skip to content

Read-only version: For security reasons, the Research Information System (FIS) has been temporarily replaced by this read-only version. All public content and full texts remain available; login, editing, submission and statistics are not available. Questions: fis@uni-bamberg.de

Home › Publications › Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance

Publication

Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance

Klett, N.; Dohrenbusch, R.; Siegmann, E.M.; u. a. (2026): Criteria-Based Validity Assessment in Legal Cases Involving Pension and Accident Insurance, in: Psychological injury and law, New York, NY: Springer, Jg. 19, Nr. 2, 19, S. 1–16, doi: 10.1007/s12207-026-09567-w.

Details

Faculty/Chair
Faculty/Professorship
Author
ORCID iDKlett, N.; Dohrenbusch, R.; Siegmann, E.M.; ORCID iDSchütz, A.; Kornhuber, J.; Röhner, J.; Keller, F.; Capito, E.S.; Grömer, T.
Title of the Journal
Psychological injury and law
ISSN
1938-9728
1938-971X
Publisher Information
Springer : New York, NY
Year of publication
2026
Volume
19
Issue
2, 19
Language
English
DOI
Abstract

Background: Medical expert witness assessments (MEWAs) evaluate case validity on the basis of both psychometric and non-psychometric modalities. Although symptom validity tests (SVTs) and performance validity tests (PVTs) are widely used, many thresholds were developed in analogue and known-groups validation contexts, and their transferability to MEWAs remains uncertain. Prior research validated a Criteria-Based Validity Assessment (CVA) as a multimodal framework for assessing case plausibility, but it remained unclear whether CVA and psychometric thresholds perform similarly across different legal contexts, such as pension insurance versus accident insurance evaluations. Objective: This study aimed to investigate differences in CVA, SVT, and PVT results across pension and accident insurance cases. Methods: A total of 721 MEWAs (572 pension; 149 accident) were analyzed. CVA criteria were rated by trained raters, and response biases were assessed psychometrically using the SIMS and the ASTM. Two-component beta-binomial mixture models were applied to derive CVA plausibility thresholds. Results: Mixture modeling reliably identified a distinct bimodal distribution of conspicuous CVA criteria counts, interpreted as plausible and implausible subgroups in both pension and accident cases, with ≥4 conspicuous CVA criteria representing the optimal plausibility threshold. Pension claimants showed significantly higher SIMS scores and lower ASTM scores than accident claimants, independent of case plausibility. Conclusion: CVA can be used to assess validity information collected from multiple data sources (longitudinal and cross-sectional) and to assess the validity of health-related claims across different legal settings. CVA, however, was not a tool for measuring context-specific response biases. Cases with ≤2 conspicuous CVA criteria may be valid, cases with three conspicuous criteria require individual examination because feigning is possible but not certain, and ≥4 conspicuous criteria supported a conservative classification of CVA-defined case implausibility.

Keywords
Criteria-Based Validity Assessment
Medical expert witness assessment
Pension insurance
Accident insurance
Symptom validity test
Performance validity test
DDC Classification
150 Psychology
RVK Classification
CW 6500
Type
Article
URI
Activation date
2026-06-12
Project(s)

Permalink: https://fis.uni-bamberg.de/handle/uniba/115552 · Data as JSON · Cite: BibTeX · RIS

Data as of: 2026-11-16

Restricted read-only access: login, editing and submission are temporarily disabled.