Collective Agency of Horizontal Regulatory Organizations in Global Environmental and Financial Market Governance
Completed
Details
Project data
- Title
- Collective Agency of Horizontal Regulatory Organizations in Global Environmental and Financial Market Governance
- Project leader
- Department
- Person involved
- Vizitiu, Patrick
- Start date
- 2020-12-01
- End date
- 2025-06-30
- Category
- Sonstiges
- potential profile area
- Actions of and in Organisations
Project description
- Acronym
- Horizontal Collective Actors
- Description
The project will elaborate theoretically and investigate empirically whether and how horizontal regulatory organizations in two important areas of global politics – environmental protection and financial market regulation – gain collective agency along the dimensions of decision-making authority and autonomy. We will theorize mechanisms of autonomy-generation and of authority acquisition and subject them to an empirical test in a mixed-methods design. The project is part of a research group on Non-hierarchical Collective Agency
The two policy fields host numerous specialized international or transnational governance institutions, that are authorized to produce and administer rules – and thus govern areas of international relations. However, in contrast to full-fledged international organizations, these institutions typically lack powerful bureaucracies and are dominated by their (state and non-state) members. Important examples include the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and its Kyoto Protocol and Paris Agreement, the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer, the Basel Committee of Banking Supervision (BCBS), and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). It is highly important for understanding contemporary international politics whether such institutions merely provide forums for interaction of their members, or whether they constitute organizations that may gain the ability to act in their own right and may become subject to processes of autonomization, thus gradually evading control by their members, as is widely expected for organizations.
Theoretically, horizontal international and transnational institutions raise intricate issues of collective agency, which are so far largely ignored in political science and international relations. The project seeks to elucidate how collective agency can arise from interaction among the members of an organization. In line with the recent debate on international political authority and drawing on James Coleman’s resource-based theory of corporate action, we argue that horizontal transnational and international regulatory institutions are organizations that, like any other organization, can become actors in their own right and acquire autonomy (a specific organizational rationale), despite close control by their members. To understand how this occurs, we will develop theoretical mechanisms showing how, and under which conditions, even strategically acting members of horizontal organizations can be expected to be enmeshed in institutional processes that generate organizational autonomy or decision-making authority.
Empiricially, the project investigates the forms of agency developed by transnational and international regulatory institutions in the two policy fields of environmental protection and financial market regulation, and what this means for global policy making. On the one hand, we examine patterns of resource endowment and autonomy and their development over time for a set of 40 horizontal organizations from the two policy fields, based on a novel database of institutional characteristics. On the other hand, we will examine in selected case studies whether and how previously developed theoretical mechanisms translate into actual organizational autonomy.
- Area of research
- International Relations
- Keywords
- International Organizations
Grants
| Donor of third party funds | Funding Code | URL |
|---|---|---|
| DFG Sachbeihilfe Normalverfügung | 443226341 | https://gepris.dfg.de/gepris/projekt/443226341 |
Publications
- Member-dominated international organizations as actors : a bottom-up theory of corporate agency – Gehring, Thomas; Urbanski, Kevin · 2023 · Article
- Member-dominated international organizations as actors : a bottom-up theory of corporate agency – Gehring, Thomas; Urbanski, Kevin · 2023 · Article
- Analogy-based Collective Decision-making and Incremental Change in International Organizations – Dörfler, Thomas; Gehring, Thomas · 2022 · Article
- Analogy-based Collective Decision-making and Incremental Change in International Organizations – Dörfler, Thomas; Gehring, Thomas · 2021 · Article
- The European Union and international sanctions : a model of emerging actorness – Urbanski, Kevin · 2020 · Doctoralthesis
- Precedent and doctrine in organisational decision-making: the power of informal institutional rules in the United Nations Security Council’s activities on terrorism – Gehring, Thomas; Dorsch, Christian; Dörfler, Thomas · 2019 · Article
- Constitutive Mechanisms of UN Security Council Practices. Precedent Pressure, Ratchet Effect and Council Action Regarding Intrastate Conflicts – Gehring, Thomas; Dörfler, Thomas · 2019 · Article
- Credible commitment without independent regulatory agent: Evidence from the Security Council's United Nations Compensation Commission – Becker, Manuel; Dörfler, Thomas; Gehring, Thomas · 2018 · Article
- International Environmental regimes : Dynamic sectoral legal systems – Gehring, Thomas · 2018 · Article
- Die Anerkennung der Europäischen Union in internationalen Kooperationsprojekten – Mühleck, Marc · 2016 · Doctoralthesis
- European Union Actorness in International Institutions: Why the EU is Recognized as an Actor in Some International Institutions, but Not in Others – Gehring, Thomas; Oberthür, Sebastian; Mühleck, Marc · 2013 · Article
- International Environmental Regimes as Decision Machines – Gehring, Thomas · 2012 · Contribution to an Articlecollection
- Making an Administrative Trustee Agent Accountable. Reason-based Decision-making within the Kyoto Protocol's Clean Development Mechanism – Gehring, Thomas; Plocher, Isabel · 2009 · Article
- Internationale Organisationen als Organisationen : was die Organisationsforschung von der Systemtheorie lernen kann – Gehring, Thomas · 2009 · Contribution to an Articlecollection
- Dynamic international regimes : institutions for international environmental governance – Gehring, Thomas · 1994 · Doctoralthesis
- International environmental regimes : dynamic sectoral legal systems – Gehring, Thomas · 1991 · Article